Stay If You Dare - Vacation Rentals in Seminole Island

Dates

Price

Guests

More

When do you want to travel?

We search multiple sites to find you the best prices.

Compare Price with Other Partners

From US $552

         

9.6 (37 Reviews)

Cabin

Indian Hallow Blue Jacket Lodge

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pool

• Lima
• Lakeview

View Availability

From US $365

         

|

10.0 (1 Review)

House

Waterfront with Boat Dock Retreat on Indian Lake

• Parking
• View
• Ocean View

• Ohio
• Saint Johns

View Availability

From US $149

         

9.4 (90 Reviews)

Hotel

Cobblestone Hotel & Suites-RussellsPoint

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pool

• Ohio
• Russells Point

View Availability

From US $259

         

10.0 (108 Reviews)

House

Phoebe’s Waterfront Lakehouse . Close to Mad River Mountain Skiing & Cranberry's

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• Lima
• Lakeview

View Availability

From US $286

         

|

10.0 (1 Review)

House

Indian Lake Vacation Rental with Fire Pit and Sauna

• Parking
• View
• Accessibility

• Lima
• Lakeview

View Availability

From US $882

         

10.0 (80 Reviews)

House

Private waterfront, large firepit and covered boat dock!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Lima
• Lakeview

View Availability

From US $148

         

|

10.0 (1 Review)

House

Waterfront Lakeview Cottage with Dock and Lift!

• Parking
• Pool
• Accessibility

• Lima
• Lakeview

View Availability

From US $260

         

10.0 (75 Reviews)

House

Escape to Indian Lake! Boating-Tubing-Kayaking-Fishing & more!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• Ohio
• Saint Johns

View Availability

From US $388

         

10.0 (73 Reviews)

House

Popular Lakefront Home With Beautiful Views.

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Ohio
• Russells Point

View Availability

From US $263

         

10.0 (67 Reviews)

Cottage

Seminole Cottage 2025 Calendar FINALLY OPEN! BOOK your next Get-A-Way!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• Lima
• Lakeview

View Availability

From US $165

         

10.0 (67 Reviews)

Cottage

Ptoobies Place- waterfront cottage with boat dock & NEW deck!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• Lima
• Lakeview

View Availability

From US $121

         

10.0 (63 Reviews)

House

Home of the Brave ~ Indian Lake

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Lima
• Lakeview

View Availability

From US $298

         

10.0 (43 Reviews)

House

Roxie's Modern Lake Front House on the water!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• Ohio
• Russells Point

View Availability

From US $474

         

10.0 (42 Reviews)

Cabin

Waterfront Cabin with Hot Tub, Outside Bar & Private Dock!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Ohio
• Russells Point

View Availability

From US $392

         

10.0 (42 Reviews)

House

Amazing Waterfront Family Getaway with WiFi - on Orchard Island in Indian Lake

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Lima
• Lakeview

View Availability

From US $243

         

10.0 (36 Reviews)

House

The Vintage Lake House w/Private Dock

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Ohio
• Russells Point

View Availability

From US $146

         

10.0 (35 Reviews)

House

Little Blue Bungalow - Amazing Views + Boat Dock!

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• Balcony/Terrace

• Ohio
• Russells Point

View Availability

From US $201

         

10.0 (32 Reviews)

House

Lakefront views at our Long Island Lookout!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• Ohio
• Saint Johns

View Availability

From US $385

         

10.0 (31 Reviews)

House

Waterfront Lake House, 20 person Tiki, Outdoor firepit, & Great location!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• Ohio
• Saint Johns

View Availability

From US $330

         

10.0 (31 Reviews)

House

The Peak of Indian Lake, Pickle Ball Court and Boat Dock!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Ohio
• Russells Point

View Availability

From US $216

         

10.0 (31 Reviews)

Cottage

Island Cottage w/Pool Table & Walking distance to Cranberry!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Lima
• Lakeview

View Availability

From US $757

         

10.0 (27 Reviews)

House

SUNSET RETREAT-Brand New Luxury 4BR, 4.5BA waterfront, best sunsets on the lake!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Ohio
• Russells Point

View Availability

From US $140

         

10.0 (27 Reviews)

Cottage

Historic Tiny Cottage just steps to the lake. Pet Friendly!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• Ohio
• Russells Point

View Availability

From US $167

         

10.0 (23 Reviews)

House

Updated home on 2/3 acre w/HOT TUB and BOAT DOCK! Walk to 3 bars/eateries

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Lima
• Lakeview

View Availability

★ Pro Tip: Stayifyoudare makes it easy to compare the best listings on Stayifyoudare homes from online vacation rental OTAs, including Booking.com and more. Use the Advanced Filter feature at the top to easily flip between Stayifyoudare homes, vacation rentals, bed and breakfasts, private Airbnb-style rentals availability, eco-friendly properties, property type, cancellation policies, prices, and several different options. All these make it easier to find the perfect accommodation for your next vacation in Seminole Island.