Stay If You Dare - Vacation Rentals in Fire Island Lighthouse

Dates

Price

Guests

More

When do you want to travel?

We search multiple sites to find you the best prices.

Compare Price with Other Partners

From US $1,025

         

10.0 (33 Reviews)

House

Fair Harbor: 30 Seconds to the Ocean ★

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Bay Shore
• Fair Harbor

View Availability

From US $1,706

         

|

10.0 (1 Review)

House

Robbins Rest Retreat

• Pet Friendly
• View
• Wheelchair Accessible

• New York
• Ocean Beach

View Availability

From US $1,104

         

10.0 (13 Reviews)

House

Fire Island Beach House - Atlantique

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• View

• Bay Shore
• Atlantique

View Availability

From US $959

         

10.0 (7 Reviews)

House

Fire Island Beach House

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• View

• Bay Shore
• Atlantique

View Availability

From US $992

         

10.0 (2 Reviews)

House

Fire Island Home w/Guest Cottage in Atlantique

• Air Conditioner
• Pet Friendly
• TV

• Bay Shore
• Atlantique

View Availability

From US $1,117

         

10.0 (1 Review)

House

Chalet-by-the-Sea

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• View

• Bay Shore
• Kismet

View Availability

From US $931

         

9.8 (31 Reviews)

House

Kismet, 4 bedroom Fire Island family house "IMAGINE"

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• View

• Bay Shore
• Kismet

View Availability

From US $1,143

         

9.6 (4 Reviews)

House

Bright airy Fair Harbor home with ocean views steps from the soft sandy beach

• TV
• Security/Safety
• Bedding/Linens

• Bay Shore
• Fair Harbor

View Availability

From US $783

         

8.2 (16 Reviews)

House

Fair Harbor Living - Barefoot Beach Getaway

• Air Conditioner
• Pet Friendly
• TV

• Bay Shore
• Fair Harbor

View Availability

From US $834

         

7.0 (2 Reviews)

Cottage

Fair Harbor Fire island

• Air Conditioner
• Pet Friendly
• Balcony/Terrace

• Bay Shore
• Fair Harbor

View Availability

From US $973

         

6.2 (14 Reviews)

House

Large Home with Ocean Views, Fireplace, and Gas Grill - Dogs Welcome

• Air Conditioner
• Pet Friendly
• TV

• New York
• Ocean Beach

View Availability

From US $6,863

         

New

House

Cozy 4-bedroom House. Ocean Block

• Air Conditioner
• Balcony/Terrace
• Security/Safety

• New York
• Fire Island

View Availability

From US $1,167

         

New

House

Ocean Beach

• Air Conditioner
• Pet Friendly
• Security/Safety

• New York
• Ocean Beach

View Availability

From US $1,020

         

New

House

Fire Island Beach House

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• View

• Bay Shore
• Kismet

View Availability

From US $800

         

9.8 (39 Reviews)

Cottage

Chill Beachfront Cottage Amazing Bay & Sunset Views! Large Private Outdoor space

• Air Conditioner
• Pet Friendly
• TV

• Bay Shore
• Fair Harbor

View Availability

From US $486

         

9.6 (23 Reviews)

House

Newly renovated beach house in Fair Harbor, Fire Island. Ultrafast Verizon Fios.

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• View

• Bay Shore
• Fair Harbor

View Availability

From US $1,491

         

9.4 (16 Reviews)

House

Short term Fire Island Beach House (Kismet)

• Air Conditioner
• Pet Friendly
• TV

• Bay Shore
• Kismet

View Availability

From US $1,493

         

10.0 (46 Reviews)

House

Ocean View ⭐️ Kismet Summer House Ocean Block 6 Bedroom

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• View

• Bay Shore
• Kismet

View Availability

From US $965

         

10.0 (16 Reviews)

House

Oceanfront waves & breezes ~ 4 bed/2 bath in Robbins Rest, Fire Island, NY

• Air Conditioner
• Pet Friendly
• TV

• New York
• Ocean Beach

View Availability

From US $849

         

10.0 (16 Reviews)

House

Fire Island Beach House ~ Magnificent Ocean and Bay Views. Steps to the Beach

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• View

• Bay Shore
• Lonelyville

View Availability

From US $604

         

10.0 (14 Reviews)

House

Bohemian Cottage - Steps from ocean and bay

• Pet Friendly
• View
• Ocean View

• Bay Shore
• Lonelyville

View Availability

From US $425

         

10.0 (6 Reviews)

House

Ocean Breezes/Ocean Views - Fair Harbor, Fire Island

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pet Friendly

• Bay Shore
• Fair Harbor

View Availability

From US $1,877

         

10.0 (4 Reviews)

House

BRAND NEW - 8 Bedroom, 4 bathroom house with BEAUTIFUL BAY VIEWS- Kismet!

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• View

• Bay Shore
• Kismet

View Availability

From US $1,502

         

|

10.0 (4 Reviews)

House

Fire Island Designer Beach House- Dunewood- Family Friendly with Tennis

• Air Conditioner
• Pet Friendly
• TV

• Bay Shore
• Fair Harbor

View Availability

★ Pro Tip: Stayifyoudare makes it easy to compare the best listings on Stayifyoudare homes from online vacation rental OTAs, including Booking.com and more. Use the Advanced Filter feature at the top to easily flip between Stayifyoudare homes, vacation rentals, bed and breakfasts, private Airbnb-style rentals availability, eco-friendly properties, property type, cancellation policies, prices, and several different options. All these make it easier to find the perfect accommodation for your next vacation in Fire Island Lighthouse.