Stay If You Dare - Vacation Rentals in Blue Gate Theater

Dates

Price

Guests

More

When do you want to travel?

We search multiple sites to find you the best prices.

Compare Price with Other Partners

From US $244

         

10.0 (62 Reviews)

Cabin

Cozy ‘Haven of Rest’ Home w/Amish Country Views!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Balcony/Terrace

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $254

         

|

10.0 (23 Reviews)

House

Shipshewana Guest House with Fire Pit!

• Parking
• Accessibility
• Security/Safety

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $126

         

9.6 (1430 Reviews)

Hotel

Blue Gate Garden Inn

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pool

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $259

         

10.0 (50 Reviews)

House

Blue Birds Perch: Stunning Home on Private Hilltop

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $156

         

|

10.0 (4 Reviews)

House

Blue Birds Perch Stunning Home on Private Hilltop

• Parking
• Accessibility
• Security/Safety

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $163

         

9.6 (1005 Reviews)

Hotel

Farmstead Inn & Conference Center

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pool

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $171

         

10.0 (44 Reviews)

House

Shipshewana Guest House with Fire Pit!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Balcony/Terrace

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $291

         

|

9.8 (14 Reviews)

House

Cozy Haven of Rest Home with Amish Country Views!

• Parking
• Accessibility
• Security/Safety

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $125

         

9.2 (1316 Reviews)

Hotel

Van Buren Hotel

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Pool

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $459

         

10.0 (19 Reviews)

Cottage

Spacious cottage by lake & walking trails, 1 mile from downtown Shipshe.

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $391

         

10.0 (4 Reviews)

House

Herons Perch: Peaceful Lakefront Cottage in Shipshewana close to all the fun!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $290

         

9.8 (137 Reviews)

Cabin

Cozy Amish Country Cabin on Shipshewana Lake!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $245

         

9.8 (32 Reviews)

House

Songbird Haven, 3 min from town, & Pumpkinvine. Full house, 3 bedroom, 2 bath.

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Balcony/Terrace

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $255

         

9.8 (31 Reviews)

House

Log Cabin Haus in Amish Country nShipshewana, Indiana

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• Security/Safety

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $242

         

9.8 (24 Reviews)

House

Cozy Home Retreat

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $289

         

8.6 (11 Reviews)

Cottage

Quiet cottage a peaceful stay!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

From US $396

         

8.0 (3 Reviews)

House

Secluded, handcrafted 4-bedroom house in Amish country, Shipshewana

• Air Conditioner
• Security/Safety
• Sports/Activities

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

New

From US $272

         

New

House

Simple Serenity Loft | Tiny Home #6 in Amish Country!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

New

From US $272

         

New

House

Serene Sanctuary | Tiny Home #1 in Amish Country!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

New

From US $272

         

New

House

Natural Nook | Tiny Home #2 in Amish Country!

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• Security/Safety

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

New

From US $267

         

New

House

Little Luxe Retreat #7 | Tiny Home + Fire Table

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• Balcony/Terrace

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

New

From US $239

         

New

House

Hearthstone Hideaway #5 | Tiny Home

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• Security/Safety

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

New

From US $239

         

New

House

Nature's Nest | Tiny Home #4 in Amish Country!

• Air Conditioner
• Parking
• TV

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

New

From US $233

         

New

House

Whispering Cottage #3 | Tiny Home

• Air Conditioner
• TV
• Security/Safety

• Indiana
• Shipshewana

View Availability

★ Pro Tip: Stayifyoudare makes it easy to compare the best listings on Stayifyoudare homes from online vacation rental OTAs, including Booking.com and more. Use the Advanced Filter feature at the top to easily flip between Stayifyoudare homes, vacation rentals, bed and breakfasts, private Airbnb-style rentals availability, eco-friendly properties, property type, cancellation policies, prices, and several different options. All these make it easier to find the perfect accommodation for your next vacation in Blue Gate Theater.